Do special teams touchdowns count in fantasy football?
Special teams touchdowns have long been a source of debate in the world of fantasy football. While many enthusiasts argue that they should be counted, others believe that they should not. The question of whether special teams touchdowns should be included in fantasy football scoring has significant implications for players and owners alike. In this article, we will explore the various perspectives on this topic and provide an in-depth analysis of the arguments for and against including special teams touchdowns in fantasy football.
Arguments for including special teams touchdowns
Proponents of counting special teams touchdowns in fantasy football argue that these plays are a significant part of the game and should be recognized in the fantasy realm. Here are some of the key reasons why they believe special teams touchdowns should be included:
1. Value to the team: Special teams touchdowns can make a substantial impact on a team’s overall performance. For example, a blocked punt that results in a touchdown can turn the tide of a game and provide a morale boost for the team.
2. Injury prevention: Including special teams touchdowns in fantasy football can incentivize teams to protect their players from injuries on special teams. If the value of these plays is recognized, teams may be more cautious when using their players on special teams units.
3. Skill and athleticism: Special teams touchdowns often require a high level of skill and athleticism. By including these plays in fantasy football, teams are rewarded for developing well-rounded players who excel in various aspects of the game.
4. Realism: Fantasy football is meant to simulate the real game as closely as possible. Including special teams touchdowns ensures that the fantasy experience reflects the full spectrum of the sport.
Arguments against including special teams touchdowns
On the other hand, there are compelling reasons why some believe special teams touchdowns should not be counted in fantasy football. Here are some of the main arguments against including these plays:
1. Unpredictability: Special teams touchdowns are often the result of a lucky bounce or a rare mistake by the opposing team. This unpredictability makes it difficult for fantasy owners to rely on these plays as a consistent source of points.
2. Ineffectiveness of special teams units: Many teams struggle to produce special teams touchdowns, making them an unreliable fantasy asset. Including these touchdowns in the scoring system could unfairly benefit teams with weaker special teams units.
3. Focus on individual skill: Fantasy football is designed to reward individual skill and performance. By including special teams touchdowns, the focus could shift away from the offensive and defensive units that are typically the main contributors to a team’s success.
4. Inconsistent scoring: The scoring of special teams touchdowns can vary greatly from league to league. This inconsistency can create confusion and frustration among fantasy owners.
Conclusion
The debate over whether special teams touchdowns should count in fantasy football is likely to continue for years to come. Both sides present valid arguments, and the decision ultimately depends on the individual preferences of players and owners. While some may argue that special teams touchdowns are an essential part of the game and should be recognized in fantasy football, others believe that these plays are too unpredictable and inconsistent to be included in the scoring system. Regardless of the outcome, it’s clear that the inclusion or exclusion of special teams touchdowns will have a lasting impact on the fantasy football landscape.
